Skip to main content

3 quarterbacks the Patriots could sign with Drake Maye likely out for the year

The Patriots will be without their superstar quarterback for the foreseeable future, leaving Tommy DeVito as the QB1.
ByGraham Wilker
Pittsburgh Steelers v Cincinnati Bengals - NFL 2025
Pittsburgh Steelers v Cincinnati Bengals - NFL 2025 | Michael Hickey/GettyImages

The New England Patriots were 5-3 just two weeks ago, having won four of their last five games. Despite a laundry list of injuries, the team was chugging along and had put themself in a strong position to make the playoffs over the first half of the season. The last two weeks have been a disaster.

After narrowly beating the Dolphins, the Patriots were mutilated by the Packers, 45-27. While an 18-point deficit is significant, it still doesn't accurately display just how outclassed the Patriots were in the game - just check the third-quarter score.

New England followed that up with a trip to Germany to face the Lions. New England lost 35-10, with Lan Larison making a fourth-quarter catch out of the backfield for the team's only touchdown. As concerning as the 25-point loss was, the primary worry was an ankle injury that ruled Drake Maye out for the game.

As of Monday, it's been reported that Maye is expected to miss significant time due to a serious injury, likely a fracture.

At this point, Maye will likely be shut down for the season. At the same time, it's not impossible that he could return for the last game or two, but there's a strong chance the team won't have anything to play for by then anyway.

Tommy DeVito finished Sunday morning's showdown. The ex-New York Giant completed just 50% of his passes for 81 yards, with a touchdown and a horrendous interception. The team's seventh-round pick, Texas Tech rookie Behren Morton, didn't see any time as the squad's emergency QB3.

With Maye set to miss significant time, if not the entire season, the team looking into other quarterbacks should be expected.

3 quarterbacks the Patriots could look to add after Drake Maye's ankle injury

Jake Browning, Chargers Practice Squad

Browning is among the best options available this time of year. The former Washington Husky spent time with the Vikings and Bengals before signing with the Buccaneers in the offseason. After losing the backup job to UDFA Jalon Daniels, the team released him.

He signed with the Chargers' practice squad in October.

Browning has played 17 games and made 10 starts since entering the league in 2019. He has a 4-6 record as a starter and has completed 68.5% of his passes, totaling 22 touchdowns and 15 interceptions.

He won all four of his wins in 2023 with the Bengals. He led Cincinnati to a 4-3 record, completing 70.4% of his passes for 276.6 passing yards per game. He totaled 15 touchdowns and 7 interceptions during that stretch.

Browning started three games in 2025, and his luck was different than in 2023. He didn't win a game as a starter, but he did score 24 points in just under three quarters against the Jaguars in Week 2. He threw three interceptions in as many quarters.

His reign would end in Week 6, after the Bengals traded for Joe Flacco. The Bengals averaged just 12.3 PPG, with Browning starting that season with 13 points in total through the first two games.

Browning is a more volatile spot starter than most backups, but at his best, he can help a team win games.

Shane Buechele, Bills Practice Squad

While Buechele has attempted just 14 passes in his NFL career, his extensive preseason action has kept him in the mix as a backup to both Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen, as he has had two stints with both the Chiefs and the Bills.

The former Texas and SMU quarterback is now on the Bills' practice squad and was elevated on Sunday for their matchup against the Jets.

In 2025, his time with the Chiefs was the only time he threw a pass, going 7/14 for 88 yards. Across six years of preseason games, however, he's totaled 1,896 yards, passing for 11 touchdowns and 7 interceptions while maintaining a 66.7% completion rate.

In his most recent campaign in August, the 28-year-old went 37/57 (64.9%) for 357 yards and a touchdown.

Buechele would compete with DeVito and Morton for the starting job with Maye out. While he doesn't offer the proven regular-season success of other backups in the league, he's been with some of the league's most innovative offenses over the past half-decade, which is notable.

Adding Buechele to the roster could be wise, even if just to push DeVito and Morton until one manages to separate themselves as a starter,

Jimmy Garoppolo, Free Agent

Saving the flashiest option for last, 35-year-old Garoppolo remains a free agent. While he hasn't thrown a pass since the 2024 season, he may still give the Patriots their best chance to win compared to anyone else available at this point.

Jimmy G was widely seen as Tom Brady's successor in the mid-2010s. In 2016, Brady was suspended for the first four games for his involvement in the Deflategate scandal, and Garoppolo was called up.

The former Eastern Illinois signal-caller saw action in six games that season, totaling five touchdowns without an interception.

He'd be traded to the 49ers the next season, where he'd spend six seasons. In 57 regular-season games for the Niners, he finished 38-17 as a starter, with 89 total touchdowns and 42 interceptions. In six playoff games in San Francisco, he totaled 4 touchdowns and 6 interceptions.

The Niners would lose to the Chiefs in the 2019 Super Bowl and fall short in the 2021 NFC Championship Game to the Rams, the eventual Super Bowl champions.

Garoppolo signed with the Josh McDaniels-led Raiders after Brock Purdy secured his position as the QB of the future in Santa Clara. His lone season with Las Vegas was a disaster, with 7 touchdowns and 9 interceptions in 7 games. He was 3-3 as a starter and was released in the offseason.

He spent the next two seasons with the Rams as a backup, passing for 334 yards, throwing two touchdowns, and throwing an interception in his only start. He didn't throw a ball last season and is now a free agent.

Given his experience in McDaniels' system, he likely wouldn't face a steep learning curve on offense. Furthermore, New England's bye week would give Garoppolo more time to learn the team's playbook.

The 5-5 Patriots have the opportunity to make a playoff push over their last seven games. They've slipped to the eighth seed after their loss to the Lions, but still have a 41% chance of making the postseason, according to NFL.com.

A Jimmy G reunion could give them the best chance of raising that metric.

Add us as a preferred source on Google