Skip to main content

Patriots best Drake Maye replacement might be an old Josh McDaniels friend

BySara Marshall
NFC Wild Card Playoffs: Los Angeles Rams v Carolina Panthers
NFC Wild Card Playoffs: Los Angeles Rams v Carolina Panthers | David Jensen/GettyImages

The Patriots' 2026 season might go down as one of the most cursed years in recent memory. Not only have they dealt with a slew of injuries, particularly on offense, which has made winning much more difficult, but now they're losing their starting quarterback after a play by DE Aidan Hutchinson took them both out of their Week 10 matchup.

Current reporting suggests Drake Maye suffered a fractured ankle while the team was overseas in Munich this past weekend, and the quarterback is set to undergo further testing to determine the injury's severity.

This all but finishes the Patriots' season as they head into their bye week at 5-5, with a lot of difficult games left on the schedule. Because of that, they might want to invest in another signal-caller after seeing Tommy DeVito struggle against the second-worst pass defense on Sunday, and the best man for the job might be Jimmy Garoppolo.

The 35-year-old was drafted by New England in 2014 and started 2 games while Tom Brady was suspended during the 2016 season. He eventually became the 49ers' quarterback for six years, even taking them to the Super Bowl, before spending time with the Raiders and Rams last year.

He remains a free agent halfway through the season, and although he's not a quarterback that will necessarily make them the most competitive team moving forward, he would surely look better than DeVito did against the Lions.

Jimmy Garoppolo might be the Patriots' best quarterback option with Drake Maye out

There's a fair argument that the Patriots' hopes of doing anything great this season are officially over, so they don't have to worry about being too competitive going forward, especially since they've lost so many players to injuries.

And while that would be difficult to debate, there are still winnable games on the schedule, particularly against the Chargers, Dolphins, and Jets, and it would be a shame not to try to win those matchups.

Based on what we saw with DeVito on Sunday, it doesn't look like he's equipped to be the starter moving forward, and Garoppolo would, at the very least, give them a chance to be competitive and maybe win a few more games before the year is over.

At this point, they're more or less competing for a desirable spot in the draft order, and although wins move them down, they still need to be aware of team morale and ensure that their current roster wants to play and stay with the team before completely losing the locker room.

Rumors have suggested things have been heading that way over the last few weeks, so losing Maye will only make it worse. But winning more games always helps that.

Garoppolo hasn't played in 2026, and he hasn't played much since the 2023 season when he was with McDaniels in Las Vegas. But his familiarity with the play-caller, his veteran leadership, and his league experience are invaluable for a team in the Patriots' position right now.

Given the limited talent available in free agency, he's the most sensible signing who would plug in immediately and give them their best chance to compete and potentially win another game or two.

That's worth the short-term investment.

Add us as a preferred source on Google