To say that the A.J. Brown experience has been frustrating would be a massive understatement. The former Philadelphia Eagles wide receiver has been hurt or a non-factor in his first season with the New England Patriots.
The fans have every right to feel bad about this transaction, but he shouldn't be blamed for getting hurt. He clearly hasn't been at full strength even when he's suited up, and he's not the only problem on offense.
That's why former Tennessee Titans general manager Ran Carthon missed the point with his take on this situation. In an appearance on CBS Sports, he hinted that teams facing such situations should just cut their losses.
The New England Patriots shouldn't even consider moving on from A.J. Brown
“You don’t want to compound a mistake by holding on to it too long,” Carthon said. “You cut your losses.”
While Carthon clarified that he didn't necessarily mean that's the case with Brown, he also hinted that some guys can be a disruptive locker-room presence for young teams. He wasn't in Tennessee when they traded Brown, but he may have heard stories or have some intel:
“You don’t want to have anyone that’s going to come in and disrupt your culture, especially as you’re trying to establish a new culture,” Carthon added.
However, there haven't been any reports of Brown being a burden or a toxic locker-room presence. Also, it's not like Mike Vrabel didn't know the guy; he coached him for years and helped him become the superstar he is nowadays.
This situation has been far from ideal, and players rarely get healthier as they grow older, but it's way too early to call this trade a miss. This has just been one of those seasons where everything that could've gone wrong has gone terribly wrong, and that's not on Brown.
Carthon is right that general managers shouldn't double down on obvious mistakes to prove a point and look like the smartest guys in the room, but there's no way the Patriots will move on from Brown after this season.
Why would they?
What they should do, however, is evaluate whether it still makes sense to keep playing him. He's banged up and has dealt with multiple ailments this season, and with Drake Maye set to miss extended time, the Pats might have to wave the white flag sooner than expected.
Other than that, they should keep him for as long as he wants to be there, especially if he's not a distraction. History isn't necessarily on his side, but giving up on him after four games makes no sense.
