Skip to main content

Patriots needed just 10 games to have buyer's remorse on A.J. Brown

What's going on with him?
ByErnesto Cova
New England Patriots wide receiver A.J. Brown (1) looks on
New England Patriots wide receiver A.J. Brown (1) looks on | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Fresh off a heartbreaking Super Bowl loss, the New England Patriots spent most of their offseason focused on one man: A.J. Brown. After months of rumors and back-and-forth, he finally arrived in Foxborough.

The Browns gave up a 2028 first-round pick and a 2027 fifth-round pick to land the former All-Pro wide receiver. It was a steep price to pay for someone who clearly wanted to leave his team, but it was well worth it... or so it seemed.

Fast forward to today, and the Patriots may not feel the same way. Brown has barely played, has been banged up, and has been a non-factor when he has taken the field. It's early, but his trade is starting to look like a losing endeavor.

The Patriots should sit A.J. Brown until he's finally healthy

Midway through the season, Brown has already missed six games with four different injuries. He's dealt with a left thumb dislocation, a right high-ankle sprain, a knee flare-up, and now a hamstring injury after a loss to the Detroit Lions.

In the four games he's actually played, he's hauled in just 11 receptions on 26 targets for 128 yards and no touchdowns. He has one fumble (recovered), three drops, and averages just 11.6 yards per catch and 32.0 yards per game.

Of course, it's hard to blame a player who's clearly not healthy, but this is a cruel business, and it doesn't change the fact that he's underachieving. He has a long injury history, and it's hard to believe he'll get healthier in his 30s.

That only raises more questions about the Patriots' decision to make a run at him this offseason. He's signed through the 2029 season, with a void year worth $53,520,000 for the 2030 campaign, according to Spotrac.

Granted, it's easy to have all the answers after the fact, so it's not like the Patriots made a short-sighted or reckless move, but there were definitely some red flags. He had a history of insubordination and wasn't a team-first guy, so there were definitely risks.

Brown clearly wants to be out there, and the Patriots may have done him more harm than good by rushing him back onto the field. They're now 5-5, so it's too early to throw in the towel, but they should still be smarter with their star wide receiver.

The Patriots should sit Brown for as long as it takes to get him back to full strength, even if that means shutting him down for the season. They gave up too much to reunite him with Mike Vrabel, but he's been a shell of himself.

He's never been great at taking criticism, so protecting him from further injury may also keep him out of the public eye and prevent this concerning situation from becoming a P.R. crisis or another distraction.

Add us as a preferred source on Google