A Super Bowl run in Year 1 of a new head coach and Year 2 of a quarterback's career is rare in the NFL, so when the Patriots achieved it last season, it was a remarkable feat that deserved a lot of praise.
Although they ended up losing to the Seahawks, it was still an accomplishment to reach their first Championship game since the 2018 season, and it seemed the new regime Vrabel brought in played a big role.
They put together a capable roster, though not the most impressive, and reached the pinnacle of success every NFL team strives for. So, heading into the 2026 offseason, they just had to make the right personnel decisions and keep the momentum going into another season.
The problem is, and we saw it pretty quickly, that they made some questionable choices with the roster, particularly those they released or didn't re-sign, and through 10 games this season, arguably way before, those choices have come back to haunt them.
That was beyond apparent over the past two weeks, and it has Patriots fans questioning Eliot Wolf's decision-making, especially since some of the most notable players they moved on from are thriving elsewhere.
Patriots' latest loss was another smack in the face for regrettable offseason decisions
When the offense was struggling at the start of the season, you couldn't go a few minutes on social media without seeing a Patriots fan reminiscing about the good days with Kayshon Boutte and Stefon Diggs making plays when they needed it the most.
Both are making waves with their new teams: Boutte had the best game of his Texans tenure last week, recording two touchdowns, and Diggs has become a go-to WR1 for Jayden Daniels and the Commanders since Terry McLaurin suffered a season-ending injury.
Releasing Diggs just one year into his 3-year contract was questionable from the start, and it looks even worse now that rumors of locker-room awkwardness have surfaced. The veteran was a voice behind the scenes, and it sounds like he's missed more than just what he does on the field.
Trading Boutte was considered just as bad, too, since it was the first time the Patriots appeared to have a jam-packed receiving corps in a long time. Because the front office believed he would be a "healthy scratch," they viewed his trade value as more important, even though A.J. Brown's Week 1 injury and Romeo Doubs' Week 6 injury would've made him an invaluable weapon for Maye immediately.
Although there are still times when fans wish they were still on the roster, the focus has shifted to the defense in recent weeks, as they are playing so poorly that it's almost difficult to imagine they were a top-10 group last year.
With the apparent struggles of the secondary and Christian Gonzalez playing the worst, Jaylinn Hawkins has been mentioned a lot over the past two weeks. He was becoming a great partner for Craig Woodson and looked like the future of the position, only for Wolf and Co. to pass on bringing him back.
Then there are the defensive line's struggles, which has drawn emotions over the Patriots' decision not to match the offer the Chiefs made to Khyiris Tonga. It was only a matter of a few thousand dollars, which makes the situation even worse, but seeing how much they've struggled to stop the run this season makes it even more regrettable than it was at first.
The same can be said about K'Lavon Chaisson, who signed a one-year prove-it deal with the Patriots last offseason, performed better than expected, earned a new contract, only to be passed over for another former Vrabel guy, Dre'Mont Jones.
Because the players they moved on from were major producers at this point in the season, Wolf's decisions look even worse. That's not a group that would have let opposing offenses score 80 combined points and record nearly 1,000 yards over the last two weeks, further proving how underrated they were last year.
This is a part of Wolf's job that won't escape him any time soon, and it surely won't quiet the noise the rest of the season if the defense continues to struggle the way we've seen over the past few weeks.
