It's been nearly two years since Jimmy Garoppolo last took the field. He last played on January 5, 2025, leading the Los Angeles Rams with 334 yards, two touchdowns, and one pick in a 30-25 loss to the Seattle Seahawks.
That's why, even though they should be desperate for help at the most important position in sports, the New England Patriots should probably pump the brakes here. He might not be in good enough shape to save the season after Drake Maye's injury.
Garoppolo is already familiar with Josh McDaniels' system, and at just 35, he might still have something left in the tank. That said, he might need time to get his legs back under him, and the Patriots can't afford that luxury.
The Patriots need a quarterback, but not Jimmy Garoppolo
This isn't a knock on Garoppolo. He was an excellent quarterback before his career-altering injury, and even now, he would probably be a significant upgrade over the ever-struggling Tommy DeVito.
That said, nothing beats competition and actual reps. His mind might be all there, and his ability to read coverage and his football IQ should be the same, but it's hard to believe he can just get on the field, flick the switch, and have the timing and touch needed.
He also has a long history of injuries, and putting his body on the line behind a makeshift offensive line might be suicidal.
Things would've been much different if Garoppolo had been on the team from the jump. In hindsight, the front office's failure to invest more in the quarterback room was a huge mistake, and he would've been a no-brainer offseason addition. But after such a long layoff, one can only wonder whether he still has it.
Granted, we've seen guys like Joe Flacco and Philip Rivers get off their couches and light defenses up, but those are exceptions, and Garoppolo is more of a timing-based passer rather than a gunslinger like them.
With a 5-5 record, a challenging schedule, and injuries on both sides of the field, this is starting to feel like a lost season for Mike Vrabel's team. Maybe it's better just to cut their losses, focus on draft positioning, and let Drake Maye get back to full strength so they can run it back next season.
